Don't worry, guys:
Valentine's Day is Sunday, and you know we wouldn't leave you unarmed going into what amounts to the Super Bowl for girls. So we're back with the third annual
New Man Chick Flick Survival Guide.
In case this is your first time, here's the deal. We know that we owe the women in our lives a good night this Sunday. They put up with our stupidity, they let us watch a lot of football, and they never get enough credit. Unfortunately, for many women a good night involves a chick flick, and that's where things get tricky. Most of us prefer our movies to have more fighting than flirting.
To help balance your woman's desire for romance with your aversion to sappiness, we've scouted the current chick flicks in the theaters to find the most acceptable solution to your dilemma. Granted, we couldn't stand to actually sit down and watch all these movies one by one, but we did do a lot of investigating.
Here's the lineup, starting with the least appealing:
When In RomeAny time a fountain of love is prominently involved in a film plot, there should be a big red flag waving in every masculine brain.
When in Rome is the cleverly titled movie about a girl (Kristen Bell) from New York who takes a trip to Rome.
When in Rome (get it?), she steals coins from a fountain and is immediately set upon by a group of goofy suitors. Amid the zany hijinks, she falls for a journalist played by Josh Duhamel. This fills the romantic-comedy requirement of at least one journalist per film.
You get the feeling with a movie like this that a bunch of movie execs got in a room, put a bunch of chick-flick stereotypes in a hat and just pulled them out to create a plot. New York + Rome + fountain of love + hot journalist + goofy sidekicks =
movie.
It's possible that something like this could have been pulled off with an unbelievable cast, but that's not the case here. Kristen Bell (
Forgetting Sarah Marshall,
Heroes) and Josh Duhamel (
Transformers) have been decent in some lesser parts, but they haven't shown anything approaching the ability needed to save something like this. The goofy suitors feature some decent comedians (Danny DeVito, Will Arnett, Jon Heder) but nobody who's going to make us forget what we're watching.
When in Rome also has the unfortunate timing of releasing a few weeks ago, which means we have piles of negative reviews to browse. By all accounts, most thought that Duhamel and Bell might have been able to pull off a good romantic comedy, but there was no saving this hackneyed, ridiculous screenplay. Jake Coyle of the Associated Press says, "It's all exceptionally predictable and disappointingly laugh-free."
New Man recommendation: Avoid if at all possible. Sedatives might be necessary.Dear JohnAnother
Valentine's Day, another Nicholas Sparks adaptation. Ever since
The Notebook turned out to be one of the best romantic comedies in recent memory, studios have been churning one Sparky adaptation after another. Unfortunately for the men of the world,
The Notebook seems to have been a one-hit wonder for Sparks. What we're left with is a series of melodramatic, sappy tearjerkers.
The latest of these cheery flicks is
Dear John, which somehow managed to finally knock
Avatar out of the top box office spot last week. The film stars Amanda Seyfried (
Mean Girls,
Mamma Mia!) and Channing Tatum (
G.I. Joe) as young lovers who know each other for two weeks before Tatum leaves for military service. That's right—two weeks. The rest of the movie details their long-distance relationship as they write letters to each other. If you do happen to get dragged into this movie, don't ask your significant other why they would write paper letters when they could pick up a cell phone. You'll probably get a dirty look.
Although
Dear John put up strong box-office numbers last week, we recommend against it. First of all, the leads just don't cut the mustard. Tatum is about as expressive as cardboard, and Seyfried … well, just watch
this trailer. You'll get the idea. Lots of crying, lots of sentimentality, and lots of bad acting. This choice line from the trailer seems to sum it all up: "Dear John, tell me everything. Write it all down, that way we'll be together all the time, even if we're not together at all."
New Man recommendation: It will probably be better than When in Rome but expect to suppress the urge to roll your eyes quite a bit. There might be some spouse consoling required afterward as well.Valentine's DayLike last year, a strong movie choice for Sunday unfortunately isn't there—but of all the options,
Valentine's Day shows the most promise. It hasn't released yet, so there's a big question mark about how good it will be, but the cast alone should make it more appealing than the previous films.
Here's a quick rundown, in alphabetical order: Jessica Alba, Kathy Bates, Jessica Biel, Bradley Cooper (pictured), Patrick Dempsey, Jamie Foxx, Jennifer Garner, Topher Grace, Anne Hathaway, Ashton Kutcher, Queen Latifah, George Lopez, Shirley MacLaine and Taylor Swift. Oh, and Julia Roberts, too (also pictured).
How could they fit such a ridiculous number of stars into one movie? Instead of telling one long story,
Valentine's Day is a series of connected short stories that all take place on the day of love. Similar to last year's
He's Just Not That Into You, this movie has a style that takes out a lot of the set pieces and fluff that make chick flicks a torture and distills each story down to its bare bones.
This doesn't necessarily mean that it will be a good movie, but the nice thing is that if you hate a particular storyline, you just have to wait a few minutes for the next one to kick in. Plus, you'll probably get a kick out of seeing the sheer amount of recognizable faces they manage to cram onto the screen.
We don't know if
Valentine's Day is going to be good, but we know you probably won't enjoy the other two movies. If your wife is in the mood for a big-screen chick flick on Sunday, this is probably the best bet. However, be warned that the PG-13 rating cites "some sexual material and brief partial nudity."
New Man recommendation: It's worth a shot.Rental OptionsIf you plan on staying in this Sunday but still want to watch a flick, here are a couple of good options. Careful, though, someone might get you to admit that you secretly like them.
You've Got MailTom Hanks and Meg Ryan are the ultimate chemistry combo on screen. Throw in a charming script, supporting roles by Greg Kinnear, Dave Chappelle, Steve Zahn and Parker Posey, and you've got a romantic comedy worth watching.
SabrinaHere's one you might have forgotten about or missed entirely. We prefer the '90s remake to the original, mostly because the new one has Harrison Ford. Watching him play against Greg Kinnear and the lovely Julia Ormond is a treat.
FireproofIf you really want to make God's love for your marriage hit home, this is a great way to do it.
Fireproof was a movie phenomenon last year, and God used it in amazing ways to bring reconciliation to countless marriages.
Have a wonderful Valentine's Day, guys. Be sure to show your wife or significant other how much she really means to you, and give her the best night you can. If there's one thing worth celebrating, it's the God-given love of your wife.
If you're looking for more ideas about how to truly show your wife that you love her, check out our second
eMagazine article today and get them straight from the source's mouth.
Chris Glazier is the editor of New Man. He recently publicly admitted to liking the movie You’ve Got Mail. If you would like to comment on this article or mock him for his movie tastes, you can reach him at chriglazier@yahoo.com.